Pricing is the number-one thing makers get wrong — and it's the fastest way to work yourself to the bone for almost nothing. The good news: it's not complicated. Get your pricing right and everything else gets easier. Here's how to price for real profit, whether you're selling a little on the side or building a business.
If there's one mistake I've watched makers make over and over for 30 years, it's underpricing. They price to match someone else on Etsy, or they pick a number that "feels fair," and they end up working incredibly hard while barely breaking even. Let's make sure that's not you. Pricing done right isn't greedy — it's what lets you keep doing the work you love.
Your price is the single biggest lever in your whole business. Price too low and nothing else can save you — you can't reinvest in supplies, you burn out working too many hours for too little, and you quietly lose money on every single sale without feeling it until the math catches up.
Underpricing also sends the wrong signal. A price that's too low whispers "hobby" instead of "real shop," and it trains your customers to expect everything cheap and to wait for the next sale. Pricing for profit does the opposite: it funds your growth, respects your time, and tells buyers your work has real value. So let's price it right from the start.
You can't price for profit if you don't know what a product actually costs you to make. And most makers undercount — they remember the soap base but forget the dozen little things that add up.
Add up everything that goes into one finished product:
Work out the cost per finished product, not per batch — that's the number every pricing decision is built on. Get this right and the rest is simple arithmetic.
If you're selling on the side — at markets, to friends, on social media — keep your pricing dead simple. Don't overthink it with spreadsheets and overhead. Here's the rule:
Take your true cost and multiply it by 2. That's your retail price. A soap that costs you $3 to make sells for $6. A body butter that costs $5 sells for $10. Simple, repeatable, and it keeps you profitable from day one.
Now here's the part that trips people up, and it's the most important idea in this whole guide:
A lot of pricing advice tells you to add a separate hourly wage on top of your costs. For a one-person side hustle, you don't need to do that — and doing it usually prices you right out of the market. When you mark up cost × 2, that markup is your pay. The profit and your wages are the same thing. You're getting paid to do something you love, and the markup is how you get paid.
So don't tie yourself in knots trying to assign yourself $20 an hour and also double your costs — that's counting your pay twice. Keep it simple: cost × 2, and the profit is yours. (When you grow into a bigger business and might pay someone else to make your products, that's when labor becomes its own line — more on that in Stage 2.)
One thing to remember before you set that final number: selling isn't free. If you sell on a platform like Etsy, fees and payment processing run roughly 10% of each sale. Craft shows have booth fees. Card readers take a small cut. The cost × 2 markup gives you room to absorb these, but know they're there so a "profit" doesn't quietly shrink to nothing. Price with your selling costs in mind.
Here's a selling truth: the easiest sale you'll ever make is the next one to a customer who's already reaching for their wallet. Once someone's decided to buy, your goal is to gently get more into their basket — without giving away your profit. That's where smart bundles and "deals" come in. The trick is that they only work if you do the math first.
Say a bar of soap costs you $2 to make and sells for $6. You offer "buy 4, get the 5th free." The customer pays for 4 bars — that's $24 — and walks away with 5 bars that cost you $10 total to make. You just made a $14 profit on a single sale, moved five bars instead of one, and the customer feels like they got a deal. Everybody wins.
The rule that keeps it safe: the "free" item comes out of your margin, never below your cost. As long as the paid items still cover the cost of all the items (including the free one) and leave profit, the deal is smart. Always check before you run it.
This one does double duty. Say three soaps sell for $18 and cost you $6 to make, and the free lotion costs you $3. You've collected $18 on $9 of product — still a healthy profit — and you've put your lotion in their hands. If they love it, they come back and buy it at full price next time. The freebie isn't just a discount; it's sampling that creates future full-price sales.
A "20% off everything" sale just shrinks every sale you were already going to make — and a discount that big can quietly tell customers your regular prices were padded enough to afford it. Worse, since your costs don't drop, a 20% price cut often wipes out half your profit or more. A bundle does the opposite: it moves more product and raises the total basket while still feeling generous to the buyer, without ever signaling your prices were too high to begin with. Whenever you can, reach for a bundle or a buy-more-save offer instead of an across-the-board discount — just always do the quick math so the deal stays profitable.
Pricing right creates your profit — but profit only helps if you manage the cash so it survives. These are two different things, and confusing them is how a maker with good prices still ends up broke.
Profit is whether you made money over time. Cash flow is whether you have money in your hand right now to pay your bills. You can price perfectly and still run dry if you spend all the cash from a good sales day, then can't afford your next batch of supplies. The cash in your pocket after a market isn't all yours to spend — a chunk of it is already owed to the supplies that made those products.
The habit that protects you: after a sale or a show, set aside what covers your next batch and any supply costs first, and only treat what's left as profit. (We cover this hands-on in selling at craft shows and farmers markets.) Good pricing builds the margin; good cash habits keep it.
When your side hustle grows into a real business — more volume, maybe help, maybe wholesale — your pricing gets more sophisticated. The simple cost × 2 was perfect for the solo maker, but now the math changes.
Once you might pay someone else to make your products, labor becomes a real line item — because you can't pay an employee out of "the joy of making." You start accounting for labor, overhead (rent, utilities, software), and all the costs the side hustler could safely ignore. As those costs grow, your markup grows too — many established makers move from doubling toward 3 to 4 times their cost to cover everything and still profit.
When you sell to a shop that resells your product, your wholesale price is typically about half your retail price. The store needs that margin to make it worth carrying you. That's why your retail markup has to be healthy in the first place — so there's room to go wholesale and still profit.
Here's the part most makers miss. When you level up and your costs rise, you have two ways to keep your profit healthy — and the smart move is to use both:
In other words: a small price bump plus smarter buying beats one big price hike every time. The bulk savings do the heavy lifting.
Once you're costing labor, overhead, bulk pricing, and wholesale, the math gets too involved to do in your head. That's exactly what our pricing calculator is for — it's the level-up tool for the serious maker who wants to price precisely and protect every point of margin. The simple cost × 2 gets you started; the calculator helps you grow.
You'll hear it eventually, and it can rattle a new maker. But if you've done your math, your prices aren't too high — they're exactly where they need to be. Don't apologize, don't over-explain, and don't drop the price on the spot. Instead, respond with warmth and offer a choice:
"Thank you for looking! These are priced for the time and the quality of the ingredients. I do keep some smaller items at a lower price point if you'd like something more budget-friendly."
That respects the customer, explains your value briefly, and points them to a lower-priced option — all without discounting your work or sounding defensive. You're running a business, not haggling at a flea market. (This pairs well with the gracious boundaries in selling to friends and family.)
Prices aren't set in stone — and most makers wait far too long to raise them. The good news: small, regular increases are barely noticed by customers but add up to real money for you. Raise your bestsellers in $1 to $3 steps, about every six months.
Signals it's time:
How to do it cleanly: just update the price and move on. Don't announce it, don't apologize. Quiet, steady increases are normal business, and the maker who never raises prices is the one slowly going backwards as costs climb.
For a one-person side hustle, take your true cost to make the item — all materials and packaging — and multiply it by 2. That's your retail price. A soap that costs $3 to make sells for $6. It's simple, repeatable, and keeps you profitable. As your business grows and you add labor and overhead, your markup grows too, often toward 3 to 4 times your cost.
If you're a solo maker, no — and trying to usually prices you out of the market. When you mark up cost × 2, that markup is your pay; the profit and your wages are the same thing, so don't count them twice. You only start costing labor as a separate line when you grow into a business where you might pay someone else to make your products.
They can be very profitable if you do the math first. If a soap costs you $2 and sells for $6, a "buy 4, get 1 free" deal means the customer pays $24 for five bars that cost you $10 to make — a $14 profit, plus you moved more product. The rule: the free item must come out of your margin, never below your cost. Always check that the paid items cover the cost of everything, including the freebie.
Usually, yes. A flat discount like "20% off everything" just shrinks every sale you were already going to make, and a big discount can even signal that your regular prices were padded. Since your costs don't drop, a 20% price cut often wipes out half your profit or more. A bundle or buy-more-save offer moves more product and raises the total basket while still feeling like a deal. A free tie-in product, like a lotion with three soaps, also lets people sample something new, which can turn into full-price sales later.
You have two levers. First, inch your prices up modestly over time. But the more powerful lever is lowering your material cost by buying supplies in larger, bulk sizes. Every dollar you save on materials drops straight to profit because your selling price doesn't change. A small price increase plus smarter bulk buying beats one big price hike, and it funds growth without pricing yourself out.
Don't apologize or drop the price. Respond warmly and offer a choice: "Thank you for looking! These are priced for the time and quality of the ingredients. I do keep some smaller items at a lower price point if you'd like something more budget-friendly." It respects the customer, explains your value, and points them to an option without discounting your work.
Raise your bestsellers in $1 to $3 steps about every six months. It's time when your material costs go up, when you're consistently sold out, when you've improved the product, or simply when it's been six months. Small increases are barely noticed by customers but add up to real money. Just update the price quietly — no announcement, no apology.
Whether you want to learn more, get inspired, or stock up on supplies — here's where to go next.
Browse every step-by-step guide we offer, organized by craft.
Tutorial HomeSeasonal makes, trending projects, and fresh ideas from our blog.
Read the BlogFree maker tools for pricing, soap & lye, resin, slime, and batch scaling.
Use the ToolsBases, fragrance, color, and everything for soap and skincare.
Shop Supplies!
